Numerical investigation of sound transmission loss of circular plates embedded with acoustic black hole
Xiaofei Du^{1} , Jianrun Zhang^{2}
^{1, 2}School of Mechanical Engineering, Southeast University, Nanjing, 211189, China
^{2}Corresponding author
Vibroengineering PROCEDIA, Vol. 30, 2020, p. 163167.
https://doi.org/10.21595/vp.2019.21186
Received 18 November 2019; accepted 25 November 2019; published 2 April 2020
JVE Conferences
The acoustic black hole (ABH) can be utilized to achieve aggregation of flexural wave in structures with the feature that the thickness gradually reduced to zero with a power exponent no less than 2. These characteristics could be applied in vibration reduction, noise attenuation or improving sound insulation. To investigate the sound transmission loss of circular plates embedded with acoustic black hole, series of vibroacoustic coupling finite element models (FEM) for TL analysis of ABH circular plates were established by automatic matched layer (AML) method in this paper and the simulation results show that the circular plate with a single ABH embedded in the center position can significantly improve the sound transmission loss in stiffnesscontrolled region, and at the firstorder resonance frequency.
 The structure of a circular plate embedded with acoustic black hole was proposed
 A FEM model for sound transmission loss analysis of ABH circular plate was established
 The ABH circular plate can significantly improve the TL below the firstorder resonance frequency
Keywords: acoustic black hole, circular plate, sound transmission loss, numerical simulation.
1. Introduction
In the past two decades, the structures embedded with acoustic black hole (ABH) have received wide attention in the application of vibration reduction or noise attenuation, and it also contributes to lightweighting of the structures [13]. Above the characteristic frequency of the structure, the ABH can effectively gather the flexural wave in the structure, and while below the characteristic frequency, multiple acoustic black holes are able to improve the loworder modal loss of the structure [4]. Mironov proposed an acoustic black hole pipe structure. By gradually increasing the effective admittance of the pipe along the axial direction, the velocity of the sound wave propagating along the pipe is gradually reduced to zero [5]. Bowyer et al. conducted experimental studies on sound radiation of vibrating rectangular plates containing tapered indentations of powerlaw profile [6] and found that when a very thin damping material is attached to an acoustic black hole region, the radiated sound power of the structure is reduced by 10 to 18 dB compared with the uniform thickness plate in the frequency range of 1 to 3 kHz [7]. Feurtado experimentally analyzed the influence of the diameter of the damping layer on the radiated sound of rectangular plates with 4×5 array of embedded ABHs in the full frequency range [8]. Then he used experimental and numerical methods to investigate the transmission loss (TL) of plates with embedded ABHs [9] and also calculated the vibroacoustic coupling properties of the ABH system based on wavenumber transformation method [10].
In this paper, numerical methods were used to analyze the effects of ABH on the sound transmission loss of circular plates. Unlike most other literatures which mainly focus on the responses of ABH structure under point drive excitation, the responses of ABH plates under diffuse sound excitation are represented in this work.
2. Theory of ABH circular plate
A circular plate embedded with a twodimensional acoustic black hole is shown in Fig. 1. The equation between the thickness of the circular plate and the radius is given by:
where $\epsilon $ is a constant number; $m$ is the taper power, $m\ge $2; $b$ is the distance between the center of the ABH and the origin of the coordinate in the $z$ direction; ${h}_{p}$ is the thickness of the uniform region of the plate. The propagation velocity of flexural wave in a thin isotropic plate is:
where $B$ is the bending stiffness, $B=Eh(x{)}^{3}/[12(1{\nu}^{2})]$; $E$ is the Young’s modulus; $\nu $ is Poisson’s ratio; $\omega $ is the angular frequency; $m$ is the areal density of the plate, $m={\rho}_{m}h\left(x\right)$; ${\rho}_{m}$ is the density of the plate material. When the flexural wave propagates from the uniform region to the ABH region, the wave velocity will be gradually reduced, the wavelength will be compressed, and the amplitude of the fluctuation will also be gradually increased. As the thickness gradually decreases to zero, the flexural wave propagates here where its cumulative phase reaches infinity, as a result it cannot be reflected back from the center of the ABH region. However, an ideal acoustic black hole cannot be realized in the actual manufacturing due to manufacturing process limitations so that the actual ABH structure must have a truncation. The truncation thickness of the model in Fig. 1 can be expressed as:
Fig. 1. A circular plate embedded with a twodimensional acoustic black hole
When sound waves are incident on a wall or partition, some of them will be reflected and some will be transmitted through the wall or partition. The transmission coefficient is defined as the ratio of transmitted energy to incident energy:
With the condition that the fluids on both sides of the plate are the same, the sound transmission loss of the circular plate can be expressed as [11]:
The sound insulation characteristics of a typical plate can be divided into four parts according to the frequency, which are called the stiffnesscontrolled region, the masscontrolled region, the coincidencecontrolled region, and the dampingcontrolled region.
3. FEM modeling of TL analysis
The sound insulation problem of an ABH circular plate is a vibroacoustic coupling process. The vibroacoustic coupled equation of this procedure in the form of a matrix can be expressed as:
where ${\mathbf{{\rm K}}}_{s}$, ${\mathbf{M}}_{s}$, ${\mathbf{C}}_{s}$ are the stiffness matrix, mass matrix and damping matrix of the unconstrained part of the structural mesh, ${\mathbf{{\rm K}}}_{c}$ is the coupling stiffness matrix, $\left\{{F}_{si}\right\}$ is the excitation load, which includes the contribution of the constraint portion of the structure, the known load and the external sound pressure load $p$ perpendicular to the surface of the structure. Besides, ${\mathbf{M}}_{c}$ is the coupled mass matrix, $\left\{{F}_{ai}\right\}$ is the excitation load, which contains the known sound pressure, the sound source in the acoustic field, and the contribution of the vibration velocity boundary.
The geometric parameters of the model used for finite element analysis are shown in Table 1. The diameter and thickness of the circular plate is 400 mm and 4 mm, the power index of ABH is $m=$2, the diameter of the ABH region is 60 mm, and the truncation thickness is 0.5 mm.
Table 1. Geometric parameters of the ABH circular plate
$\epsilon $

Power index

$d$ (mm)

Uniform thickness (mm)

Truncation thickness (mm)

ABH diameter (mm)

Plate diameter (mm)

3.89e3

2

1.5

4

0.5

60

400

Fig. 2 shows the FEM model of the ABH circular plate and the vibroacoustic coupled model for TL analysis. The ABH circular plate is meshed by a tetrahedral mesh, and the mesh size of the uniform region is 2 mm. In order to improve the calculation accuracy, the grid of the ABH region has a basic size of 1 mm and encrypts the mesh in the small curved area with a minimum size of 0.2 mm, thereby ensuring the elements on the smaller surface transition well to the units on adjacent large surfaces. The acoustic model has a size of 0.6×0.6×0.02 m. The calculated frequency has a corresponding relationship with the grid cell size. For the linear finite element model, the side length of the largest cell must be less than 1/6 of the wavelength corresponding to the highest calculated frequency, that is $L\le c/6{f}_{\mathrm{m}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{x}}$. In this paper, the calculation frequency of the transmission loss is 010 kHz, so the cell length of the mesh should not be greater than 5.6 mm. Finally, the mesh size of the acoustic finite element model of this paper is selected as 4 mm.
Fig. 2. TL analysis model of an ABH plate
a) Structural model of the ABH plate
b) Vibroacoustic coupling model
The FEM simulation was performed using the commercial software LMS Virtural.Lab. The acoustic model below the plate in Fig. 2(b) represents the reverberation chamber, and the acoustic model above the plate simulates the anechoic chamber. The ABH region of the circular plate is on the side close to the anechoic chamber, and the boundary condition of the periphery of the circular plate is clamped. A reverberation sound source is generated in the reverberation chamber, and the sound is transmitted to the anechoic chamber through the ABH plate, and finally passes through the outer wall surface of the anechoic chamber and radiates outward without reflection. The faces of the two acoustic meshes close to the structural mesh are respectively coupled with the corresponding faces of the structural mesh and the remaining faces of the two acoustic meshes are respectively applied with a diffuse sound field on the side of the reverberation chamber and a zero reflection surface on the side of the anechoic chamber by the Automatic Matched Layer (AML) method. The transmission loss of the ABH plate can be obtained by computing the sound power incident on the ABH circular plate and radiated from the plate to the anechoic chamber.
The material parameters of the ABH circular plate are shown in Table 2. The firstorder resonant frequency and the coincidence frequency of the ABH circular plate can be calculated to be approximately 350 Hz and 2900 Hz according to LMS Virtural.Lab. Therefore, the calculated frequency of 010 KHz selected in this paper covers all characteristic frequency regions from the stiffnesscontrolled region to the dampingcontrolled region.
Table 2. Geometric parameters of the ABH circular plate
Material

Young’s modulus (Pa)

Density (kg/m^{3})

Poisson’s ratio

Loss factor

Aluminum 6061

7e+10

2700

0.35

5e4

4. Results of TL simulation
The TL of an ABH circular plate with a diameter of 60 mm embedded in the center was calculated and compared with the sound transmission loss of the uniform circular plate, as shown in Fig. 3. It can be seen from Fig. 3 that, below the firstorder resonance frequency, the TL of the circular plate embedded with the 2D ABH is improved compared with the uniform circular plate and both the TLs of the two plates decrease as the frequency increases. At the firstorder resonance frequency, the acoustic loss of the circular plate embedded with the acoustic black hole is greatly improved compared with the uniform circular plate. The difference between the TL of the ABH circular plate and the uniform circular plate at this frequency is 21.13 dB. In the masscontrolled region, the TL of the circular plate embedded with ABH is larger at some frequencies; while at other frequencies, the TL of the uniform circular plate is larger, indicating that the sound insulation performance of the ABH circular plate is not improved overall in this characteristic region. At the coincidence frequency, the TL of the ABH circular plate is 8.31 dB higher than that of the uniform circular plate. While in the dampingcontrolled region, the TL of the ABH circular plate is not improved overall, but at a certain frequency, for example, 8 kHz, there is an increase of 20 dB for the TL of the ABH circular plate.
Fig. 3. TL of a circular plate embedded with a diameter of 60 mm acoustic black hole and the uniform circular plate
a) TL values from 0 to 10 kHz
b) TL differences of the two plates
5. Conclusions
In this study, a series of vibroacoustic coupling finite element models for sound transmission loss (TL) analysis of ABH circular plates were established by Automatic Matched Layer (AML) method. The simulation results show that the circular plate with a single ABH embedded in the center position can significantly improve the sound transmission loss in stiffnesscontrolled region, and at the firstorder resonance frequency and some frequencies in dampingcontrolled region. At the coincidence frequency, the TL of the ABH circular plate is 8.31 dB higher than that of the uniform circular plate. While in the dampingcontrolled region, the TL of the ABH circular plate is not improved overall, but at a certain frequency, for example, 8 kHz, there is an increase of 20 dB for the TL of the ABH circular plate.
References
 Bowyer E. P., et al. Experimental investigation of damping flexural vibrations in plates containing tapered indentations of powerlaw profile. Applied Acoustics, Vol. 74, Issue 4, 2013, p. 553560. [Publisher]
 Tang Liling, et al. Characterization of acoustic black hole effect using a onedimensional fullycoupled and waveletdecomposed semianalytical model. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 374, 2016, p. 172184. [Publisher]
 Georgiev V. B., et al. Damping of structural vibrations in beams and elliptical plates using the acoustic black hole effect. Journal of Sound and Vibration, Vol. 330, Issue 11, 2011, p. 24972508. [Publisher]
 Conlon Stephen C., Fahnline John B., Semperlotti Fabio Numerical analysis of the vibroacoustic properties of plates with embedded grids of acoustic black holes. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Vol. 137, Issue 1, 2015, p. 447457. [Publisher]
 Mironov M. A., Pislyakov V. V. Onedimensional acoustic waves in retarding structures with propagation velocity tending to zero. Acoustical Physics, Vol. 48, Issue 3, 2002, p. 347352. [Publisher]
 Bowyer Elizabeth P., Krylov Victor V. Sound radiation of rectangular plates containing tapered indentations of powerlaw profile. Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics 164ASA, Vol. 18, Issue 1, 2012, p. 113. [CrossRef]
 Bowyer E. P., Krylov Victor V. Experimental study of sound radiation by plates containing circular indentations of powerlaw profile. Applied Acoustics, Vol. 88, 2015, p. 3037. [Publisher]
 Feurtado Philip A., Conlon Stephen C. An experimental investigation of acoustic black hole dynamics at low, mid, and high frequencies. Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, Vol. 138, Issue 6, 2016, p. 16. [Publisher]
 Feurtado Philip A., Conlon Stephen C. Transmission loss of plates with embedded acoustic black holes. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Vol. 142, Issue 3, 2017, p. 13901398. [Publisher]
 Feurtado Philip A., Conlon Stephen C. Wavenumber transform analysis for acoustic black hole design. The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, Vol. 140, Issue 1, 2016, p. 718727. [Publisher]
 Olivier Robin, Berry Alain Estimating the sound transmission loss of a single partition using vibration measurements. Applied Acoustics, Vol. 141, 2018, p. 301306. [Publisher]