Nonlinear behavior analysis of Zsource DC/DC converter based on current control
Chen Yan^{1} , Zheng Yong^{2}
^{1}School of Electronic Information & Automation Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing 400054, China
^{2}Chongqing Key Laboratory of Time Grating Sensing & Advanced Testing Technology Chongqing University of Technology, Chongqing 400054, China
Journal of Vibroengineering, Vol. 15, Issue 3, 2013, p. 15761584.
Received 24 June 2013; accepted 4 September 2013; published 30 September 2013
Zsource converter as a kind of power converter will be responsible for the energy transmission and load switching and other important functions, the paper focuses on the nonlinear characteristic analysis of Zsource DC/DC converter, in the continuous conduction mode (CCM), take the Zsource converter with peak current control as the research object, establish stroboscopic mapping model for analyzing its bifurcation and chaos characteristic based on system accurate modeling. According to numerical simulation and analysis, estimate parameter range in which Zsource occur bifurcation and chaos under different design. Considering the change of reference current, input voltage and load impedance, the experiment results prove that Zsource converter stroboscopic mapping model is correct for analyzing its nonlinear behavior, which provides a theoretical basis for optimal design and control.
Keywords: Zsource DC/DC converter, nonlinear, stroboscopic mapping, CCM, bifurcation, chaos.
1. Introduction
The converter is the core of the modern power electronic system, whose operational state directly relates to the whole system performance. Thanks to the devices nonlinear and switching function, the converter using feedback control demonstrates strong nonlinear and timevarying. The nonlinear phenomenon such as bifurcation and chaos may be produced during the operating process. In the 90s last century, the researchers at home and abroad have began to analyze converter nonlinear behavior and develop control method [15].
Zsource converter as the power converter topology has a single stage topology which can operate in both buck and boost modes; it has the following merits [68]: adjusting voltage in large range, high reliability, improving system’s converting efficiency, flexibility et al. Thus, the Zsource structure inverter is especially suit for the situation of output change greatly such as photovoltaic generation [7], Zsource as power conditioning system can output favorable AC voltage and widely used in different fields [89]. When Zsource is applied in power converting system, it will reveal the strange and irregular phenomenon during the operation process such as the sudden collapse of the critical operating state, the unknown electromagnetic noise, the system unstable to run and unable work according to the actual needs etc. This is the external manifestation of converter inherent nonlinearity, bifurcation and chaos [12]. The converter working in the chaos state will cause the system to run unpredicted and uncontrolled due to its uncertainty, thus its performance is influenced seriously, and even completely unable work. However, at present the Zsource converter nonlinearity research has not been reported at home and abroad [111], so the further research will play important role on improving system operation performance.
Aiming at the nonlinear characteristic, the author mainly researches on the nonlinearity of Zsource DC/DC converter. In the CCM mode, take the converter with peak current control as the research object, establish stroboscopic mapping model for analyzing its bifurcation and chaos characteristic based on system accurate modeling. According to numerical simulation and analysis, estimate parameter range in which Zsource occur bifurcation and chaos under different design.
2. Zsource converter principle
The schematic diagram of Zsource converter with peakcurrent control mode is shown in Fig. 1, the basic principle as following: the clock signal control the switch, it sets the RS trigger at regular intervals, when $Q=1$, the switch is turned on at the beginning of the cycle and the switch current increases, as ${i}_{L}$ approaches the value of ${i}_{ref}$, comparator’s output signal overturn and make RS trigger reset, $Q=0$, the switch is turned off until the next cycle begins. In this paper, we use the peak current control method to control the Zsource DC/DC converter because it is stable, simple, response rapidly, and can limit the circuit peak current to protect the devices.
Fig. 1. Schematic diagram of Zsource converter in peakcurrent control mode
For analyzing easily, assuming that the inductors ${L}_{1}$ and ${L}_{2}$ and capacitors ${C}_{1}$ and ${C}_{2}$ have the same inductance $\left({L}_{z}\right)$ and capacitance $\left({C}_{z}\right)\text{,}$ respectively, the Zsource network becomes symmetrical. Assuming shootthrough zero vector duty cycle is $d$ in a switch period, so from literature [8] we obtain the following relationship (1)(3):
Adjusting $B$ can make output voltage/current higher or lower than input side.
3. Zsource DC/DC converter modeling and analyses in peak current control mode
3.1. Modeling of Zsource DC/DC converter
In the Zsource converter, when it works in shootthrough voltage vector state, the inverter can be equivalent to short circuit, as Fig. 2(a) shows; when it works in nonshootthrough voltage vector state, the inverter can be equivalent to a current source^{}[9], as Fig. 2(b) shows, $T$ is the clock cycle, the two operating modes as following:
Mode one: (shootthrough state)
Mode two: (nonshootthrough state)
According to (4) and (5), we have the state equation of circuit as follows:
where $\stackrel{.}{x}$ represents state variable, $x=\left[\begin{array}{c}{i}_{L}\\ {u}_{c}\end{array}\right]$, ${A}_{1}=\left[\begin{array}{cc}0& 1/L\\ \frac{1}{C}& 0\end{array}\right]$, ${A}_{2}=\left[\begin{array}{cc}0& 1/L\\ 1/C& \frac{1/R}{C}\end{array}\right]$, ${B}_{1}=0$, ${B}_{2}={\left[\begin{array}{cc}1/L& 0\end{array}\right]}^{T}$.
Fig. 2. Equivalent circuit of Zsource DC/DC converter: a) equivalent circuit of inverter, when shootthrough state, b) equivalent circuit of inverter, when nonshootthrough state
a)
b)
3.2. Stroboscopic mapping model
Assuming ${d}_{n}$ is the duty cycle of the $n$th period, ${t}_{n}=nT$, ${x}_{n}=x\left(nT\right)$, the other discrete parameters’ definition and so on, the system state equation as (6) and (7) show, we have discrete model of the $n$th period, which can be expressed as following:
where ${\phi}_{1}\left({d}_{n}T\right)={e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T}$, ${\phi}_{2}\left({\stackrel{}{d}}_{n}T\right)={e}^{{A}_{2}{\stackrel{}{d}}_{n}T}$, ${\stackrel{}{d}}_{n}=1{d}_{n}$.
As a result, simplifying the integral term of the two formulas above, we have:
Substituting (11) into (12) and we obtain the discrete mapping equation:
The converter switches from on state to off state based on the value of the switching function, it is given by:
where ${k}_{1}=[1,\mathrm{}0]$, then when $\sigma ({x}_{n},{d}_{n})=0$, the converter state changes.
4. Jacobian matrix method analyze system stability
Because of the change of system circuit parameter and influence of environment disturbance, the system can operate from former stable mode into instable mode. The Jacobian matrix method as an analytical method has been widely used for researching local bifurcation issue of nonlinear dynamic system. Firstly, set the Jacobian matrix at fixed point.
Supposed the controllable system is steadied at singlecycle state, and that the input voltage and reference voltage keep steady, set ${x}_{n}=\widehat{x}+{X}_{Q}$, ${d}_{n}=\widehat{d}+D$, take ${X}_{Q}$ and $D$ as single cycle solution of the steadystate. Adopting smallsignal linearization perturbation to process the equation (8):
According to $\sigma ({x}_{n},{d}_{n})=0$, it is available:
Thus comes to:
Substituting (17) into equation (15), we have:
In that way, the corresponding Jacobian matrix is:
where:
$\frac{\partial \sigma}{\partial {x}_{n}}={k}_{1}{e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T},\text{}\frac{\partial \sigma}{\partial {x}_{n}}={k}_{1}T{e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T}{A}_{1}{x}_{n}+{k}_{1}TB{V}_{in},\mathrm{}\mathrm{}\mathrm{}\frac{\partial f}{\partial {x}_{n}}={e}^{{A}_{2}\left(1{d}_{n}\right)T}{e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T},\mathrm{}$
$\frac{\partial f}{\partial {d}_{n}}=T{e}^{{A}_{2}\left(1{d}_{n}\right)T}{e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T}{A}_{1}{x}_{n}T{A}_{2}{e}^{{A}_{2}\left(1{d}_{n}\right)T}{e}^{{A}_{1}{d}_{n}T}{x}_{n}T{A}_{2}{e}^{{A}_{2}\left(1{d}_{n}\right)T}B{V}_{in}{d}_{n}T.$
$\lambda $ may be recorded as the eigenvalue of $J$, according to the system stability, when $\lambda $ located in unit circle, system is stable. Because the Jacobian matrix here is the ratio which is the quotient of latter iterative small perturbation item and the former, if the ratio is greater than 1, it is indicated that with the increase of iterative number, the amount of disturbance gradually increases, namely the system is unstable; if the ratio is less than 1, then system is in stable. Thus, the system may be unstable when the reference current varies.
Before calculate the eigenvalue of Jacobian matrix, firstly, obtain the steadystate periodic solutions ${X}_{Q}$ and $D$ of the Zsource converter system’s discrete mapping equation. The equilibrium point is the single cycle steadystate solution, whose calculation process as following:
Set ${x}_{n+1}={x}_{n}={X}_{Q}\text{,}$$x\left(nT+{d}_{n}T\right)={X}_{D}\text{,}$${d}_{n}=D\text{,}$ according to equation (11) and equation (12), it is available:
According to the two equations above, we obtain the solution:
At the same time, the switch function meets:
Simultaneous equations from (22) to (24), using the numerical calculation to get the steadystate periodic solutions ${X}_{Q}$ and $D$, then solve the eigenvalue of Jacobian matrix according to the steadystate periodic solution, thereby judge the system stability.
5. Numerical simulation and experimental result analysis
According to Fig. 2, given the circuit parameters as following:
${C}_{1}={C}_{2}={C}_{z}=\text{1000\mu F,}$ ${L}_{1}={L}_{2}={L}_{z}=\text{5mH,}$ ${V}_{in}=\text{80V,}$ $R=\text{20\Omega ,}$ switching frequency is 20 kHz, the inductive current reference value ${i}_{ref}$ varies from 1 A to 30 A. When given ${i}_{ref}=\text{1}\text{}\text{A}$, using numerical computation to solve steadystate periodic solution:
Here, the Jacobian matrix is:
whose eigenvalues ${\lambda}_{1}=0.2533$, ${\lambda}_{2}=0.5817$.
Because of $\left{\lambda}_{1}\right<1$ and $\left{\lambda}_{2}\right<1\text{,}$ the system is stable when ${i}_{ref}=\text{1A,}$ here $\left{\lambda}_{\mathrm{m}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{x}}\right=\mathrm{m}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{x}\left\{\right{\lambda}_{1},{\lambda}_{2}\left\right\}\text{,}$ this moment, the system is in single cycle steadystate. When ${i}_{ref}=\text{1~12}\text{}\text{A}$, the change of maximum modulus eigenvalue of Jacobian matrix as Fig. 3 shows, ${\lambda}_{1}$ and ${\lambda}_{2}$ respectively changes on the real axis, and $\left{\lambda}_{1}\right$ changes more quickly than $\left{\lambda}_{2}\right\text{,}$ according to Table 1, when ${i}_{ref}$ equal to the value between 3.4 and 3.6, the $\left{\lambda}_{\mathrm{m}\mathrm{a}\mathrm{x}}\right$ will greater than 1, then lead to the system unstable.
When ${i}_{ref}$ varies in the range of 1~30, the inductive current and capacitor voltage of Zsource networks is shown in Fig. 4. It is evident from the Fig. 4(a) and Table 1, when ${i}_{ref}<\text{3.4}\text{}\text{A}$, the system is in stable operation (one cycle) and the corresponding duty factor $D<\text{0.5}$; for the reference current further increase in reference current to 3.5 A, the system bifurcates and exhibits period II operation, here$D\approx \text{0.5}$, the system exhibits stable 2 period operation, till the reference current is increased to 6.1 A. After this, the system enters into stable 4 period operation; when ${i}_{ref}=\text{7.9~9.3}\text{}\text{A}$ the system operates in I period again, till the reference current increases beyond 9.3 A, the system begins to new bifurcation till chaos.
Fig. 3. Eigenvalues trajectory of Jacobian matrix when ${I}_{ref}$ magnify
Fig. 4. Bifurcation diagram of Zsource network when ${I}_{ref}$ changes: a) bifurcation diagram of inductive current, b) bifurcation diagram of capacitor voltage
a)
b)
Table 1. Eigenvalues trajectory table of Jacobian matrix when ${I}_{ref}$ changes
${i}_{ref}$

$D$

${\lambda}_{1}$

${\lambda}_{2}$

${i}_{ref}$

$D$

${\lambda}_{1}$

${\lambda}_{2}$

1.0

0.1381

0.2533

0.5817

3.2

0.4512

0.8750

0.9106

1.2

0.1661

0.2935

0.6289

3.4

0.4678

0.9288

0.9178

1.4

0.1939

0.3342

0.6714

3.6

0.4969

1.0329

0.9286

1.6

0.2212

0.3757

0.7097

3.8

0.5096

1.0824

0.9325

1.8

0.2480

0.4185

0.7440

…

…

…

…

2.0

0.2999

0.5093

0.8015

10

0.6011

1.5412

0.9497

2.2

0.3247

0.5574

0.8252

…

…

…

…

2.4

0.3486

0.6074

0.8458

20

0.6618

1.9900

0.9526

2.6

0.3716

0.6590

0.8635

…

…

…

…

2.8

0.4140

0.7660

0.8912

30

0.8270

4.8097

0.9528

3.0

0.4333

0.8205

0.9018

The capacitor voltage also indicates its nonlinear characteristic with ${i}_{ref}$ varies as shown in Fig. 4(b), when ${i}_{ref}<\text{1.1}\text{}\text{A}$, the system is in stable operation (one cycle), when the reference increase from 1.1 A to 3.7 A, the system bifurcates and exhibits period II operation, when the reference varies in the range from 3.7 A to 9.4 A, the system operates in quasiII period, when the reference current is increased beyond 9.4 A, the system enters into chaos state.
The Fig. 5 shows the typical experimental waveforms of Zsource network. Seen from the Fig. 5(a), when ${i}_{ref}=\text{1}\text{}\text{A}$, the system is in stable operation (one period); with the reference current ${i}_{ref}$ increasing to 5 A, the inductive current bifurcates and indicates 2 period, but the capacitor voltage is irregular, whose change is out of synchronous with the inductive current, its typical waveforms is shown in Fig. 5(b); when ${i}_{ref}=\text{8}\text{}\text{A}$, the inductive current varies from 2 period to stable 4 period, till the reference current is increased beyond 30 A, the system enters into chaos state. (Channel 1 represents inductive current ${i}_{L}$ and channel 2 represents capacitor voltage ${u}_{c}$).
Fig. 5. Typical experimental waveforms of Zsource network when ${i}_{ref}$ changes: a) ${i}_{ref}=\text{1A}$ (single period), b) ${i}_{ref}=\text{5}\text{}\text{A}$ (2 period), c) ${i}_{ref}=\text{8}\text{}\text{A}$ (4 period), d) ${i}_{ref}=\text{15}\text{}\text{A}$ (chaos state)
a)
b)
c)
d)
Assuming the given parameter as follows:
${C}_{1}={C}_{2}={C}_{z}=\text{1000\mu F,}$ ${L}_{1}={L}_{2}={L}_{z}=\text{5mH,}$ ${i}_{ref}=\text{18A,}$ $R=\text{20\Omega ,}$ switching frequency is 20 kHz, when the input voltage ${V}_{in}$ varies from 50 V to 500 V, the inductive current and capacitor voltage of Zsource networks’ bifurcation diagram is shown in Fig. 6. The Fig. 7(a)~(d) show the different typical waveforms from period to chaos. (Channel 1 represents inductive current ${i}_{L}$ and channel 2 represents capacitor voltage ${u}_{c}$).
Jacobian matrix method as an analytical method can accurately calculate the location of bifurcation points. In practical application, the Jacobian matrix method is used for locating the bifurcation point, and as a guide for the parameter design in order to ensure that the system works in the stable region. According to the location of bifurcation points, further discuss the influence of circuit parameters on the stability of the quiesent work points. According to the actual situation of photovoltaic power generation system, to select the input voltage ${V}_{in}$ and the gridconnected current reference ${i}_{ref}$ as the basis for analyzing the system stable domain when both changing. Fig. 8 shows the stability boundary curve of the system quiesent work points.
Seen from the Fig. 8, the region below the curve is stable, with the input voltage increase, the quiesent point stable range of gridreference current increases gradually. Therefore, in the design one is to try to ensure the system work in the stable region.
Fig. 6. Bifurcation diagram of Zsource network when input voltage changes: a) bifurcation diagram of inductive current, b) bifurcation diagram of capacitor voltage
a)
b)
Fig. 7. Typical experimental waveforms of Zsource network when ${V}_{in}$ changes: a) ${V}_{in}=\text{50V}$ (chaos state), b) ${V}_{in}=\text{200}\text{}\text{V}$ (2 period), c) ${V}_{in}=\text{250V}$ (4 period), d) ${V}_{in}=\text{500V}$ (1 period)
a)
b)
c)
d)
Fig. 8. Stable region boundary with parameters change
6. Conclusions
In this paper, the stroboscopic mapping method is used for analyzing nonlinear behavior of Zsource DC/DC converter. In CCM, take the Zsource DC/DC converter with peak current control as the research object, establish stroboscopic mapping model for analyzing its bifurcation and chaos characteristic based on accurate system modeling. According to numerical simulation and analysis, estimate parameter range in which Zsource DC/DC converter occur bifurcation and chaos under different design.^{}Considering the change of reference current, input voltage and load impedance, the experiment result proves that Zsource DC/DC converter stroboscopic mapping model is correct for analyzing its nonlinear behavior, which provides a theoretical basis for optimal design and control.
Acknowledgements
This study is supported by the Basic and Frontier Research Program of Chongqing Municipality (cstc2013jcyjA0531) and the Science & Technology Special Foundation of Banan District of Chongqing (2012Q120).
References
 Banerjee S., Verghese G. Nonlinear Phenomena in Power Electronics: Attractors, Bifurcations, Chaos, and Nonlinear Control. New York: IEEE Press, 2001. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang B., Qu Y. Study on the experiment and the precise discrete model of bifurcation and chaos for BUCK DC/DC converter. Proceedings of the CSEE, Vol. 23, Issue 12, 2003, p. 99103. [Search CrossRef]
 Ma X. K., Li M., Dai D., et al. Reviews of research on complex behavior of power electronic circuits and systems. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, Vol. 21, Issue 12, 2006, p. 111. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang B. Study of nonlinear chaotic phenomena of power converters and their applications. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, Vol. 20, Issue 12, 2005, p. 16. [Search CrossRef]
 Zhang B. Discussion on several fundamental problems necessary to be solved in power electronics. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, Vol. 21, Issue 3, 2006, p. 2435. [Search CrossRef]
 Peng F. Z. Zsource inverter. IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 39, Issue 2, 2003, p. 504510. [Search CrossRef]
 Huang Y., Shen M. S., Peng F. Z., et al. Zsource inverter for residential photovoltaic system. IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol. 21, Issue 6, 2006, p. 17761782. [Search CrossRef]
 Shen M. S., Joseph A., Wang J., et al. Comparison of traditional inverters and Zsource inverter for fuel cell vehicle. 8th IEEE Workshop on Power Electronics in Transportation, USA, 2004. [Search CrossRef]
 Peng F. Z., Yuan X. M., Fang X. P., et al. Zsource inverter for adjustable speed drives. IEEE Power Electronics Letters, Vol. 1, Issue 2, 2003, p. 3335. [Search CrossRef]
 Gajanayake C. J., Vilathgamuwa D. M., Poh C. L. Smallsignal and signalflowgraph modeling of switched Zsource impedance network. IEEE Power Electronics Letters, Vol. 3, Issue 3, 2005, p. 111116. [Search CrossRef]
 Gajanayake C. J., Vilathgamuwa D. M., Poh C. L. Modeling and design of multiloop closed loop controller for Zsource inverter for distributed generation. IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference, South Korea, 2006. [Search CrossRef]
 Belkhayat M., Cooley R., Abed E. H. Stability and dynamics of power systems with regulated converters. Proc. IEEE Int. Symp.Circuits Systems, Seattle, WA, 1995. [Search CrossRef]
 Chen Y. F., Chi K. T., Qiu S. S. Coexisting fastscale and slowscale instability in currentmode controlled DC/DC converters: analysis, simulation and experimental results. IEEE Transacctions on Circuits and Systems – I, Vol. 55, Issue 10, 2008, p. 33353348. [Search CrossRef]
 Wang X. M., Zhang B. Study of bifurcation and chaos in singlephase SPWM inverter. Transactions of China Electrotechnical Society, Vol. 24, Issue 1, 2009, p. 101107. [Search CrossRef]